How to Rebuild Trust:
Do's & Don'ts for Christian Husbands
By Anita Kragelund Thimm, PSAP, PMAP, BTRL
The hardest part of rebuilding trust is not finding the right words. It’s becoming safe in the moments where your wife’s pain exposes the parts of you that still want to defend, explain, rush, minimize, or hide.
If you are a Christian husband rebuilding after pornography or other types of infidelity, you probably know that confession and regret are not the end of the repair process. They are part of the beginning.
The difficult work comes afterward, when your wife is still hurting, still asking questions, and is still triggered. This is where many Christian husbands unintentionally cause more damage. Not because they don’t care, but because they reach for the wrong tools.
This article gives you a practical overview of what to stop doing and what to practice instead as you work to become a safer, steadier, and more trustworthy husband after betrayal.
Don’t confuse forgiveness with trust
Your wife may be trying to forgive you, and she may even have forgiven you. However, forgiveness is about her internal process, not about her relationship with you.
If you make it about your relationship, you end up pressuring her and may even treat her continued distrust as a spiritual failure. That may pressure her into silence, but that kind of silence will damage your relationship.
Do: Understand that what you need isn’t forgiveness, but shame work.
When you react to comments about the betrayal, shame will likely be triggered in you. If you’re a Christian, it’s natural that shame makes you want forgiveness, and while God will give you this immediately, your wife needs a healing process – not a healing event – and anger, questions, and doubt are natural parts of that process.
What you need is to allow forgiveness to become a natural part of her process as she heals, and while doing so, work on how you react to feeling shame.
Don’t expect grace to remove consequences
Receiving forgiveness will not automatically remove consequences. Forgiveness is about the act. Consequences are about the damage. Even though your wife forgives you, don’t expect that you can avoid her pain and avoid doing repair work. If you try to avoid those things, you’re really trying to avoid rebuilding trust.
Do: Realize that you’re not really looking for grace, but looking to avoid shame
When you want to avoid consequences, it’s likely either because you hate being discovered more than you hate your sinful actions or because the consequences remind you of your shameful actions.
Friend, that’s human. Both of it. What’s important is that you take it seriously, not just ignore it because it’s uncomfortable. The best thing to do with it is learn from it. And if you take the consequences of the betrayal seriously, this shows your wife that you take the betrayal seriously.
Don’t reveal the truth in phases
If you drip-feed your wife the truth about your betrayal, she will be kept in a state of not knowing if there will be more. She will always wonder, Do I know everything now? Her nervous system will remain in alert, and it will take a lot longer to heal.
Do: Prepare to have a full, structured disclosure
If you plan to tell her the whole truth in one sitting – preferably with a professional within the field of sex addiction and betrayal trauma – she may have the shock of her life, but she will get over it quicker.
This can feel really, really scary. But it’s worth it. Especially if it’s done in a structured, professionally guided setting, this can make a world of difference for trust-building.
Don’t expect “sorry” to rebuild trust
Being sorry is about your feelings more than it’s about your relationship. Yes, it’s important that you’re genuinely sorry for what you did and, no, you probably didn’t want to hurt her.
But your wife can’t feel that you’re sorry. You may be the best repenting sinner in the world, but she can only see what you do.
Do: Understand that “sorry” is only the beginning
Genuinely feeling sorry for what you did is important, because it’s what can lead to change. But feeling sorry only matters if it leads you to start taking steps towards change and keep taking whatever steps are necessary for you to get to where you need to be.
If she can only see what you do, not what you feel, stop simply saying you’re sorry and start doing the things that show her that you’re sorry.
Don’t get defensive when she brings up the betrayal
When she brings up the betrayal or the pain she feels because of it, you may tend to want to defend yourself – maybe with your intentions, maybe in the form of correcting the details of what she is saying.
If you do that, what she will hear is “I don’t really take this seriously” or “it wasn’t that bad”. That will break down trust, not rebuild it, because “wasn’t that bad” means you may not have a problem doing it again.
Do: Understand that defensiveness is a shame-based reaction
If you tend to want to minimize or defend, it’s almost always because you feel ashamed and attacked, so your brain’s fire alarm gets anxious.
If you want to rebuild trust: 1. Learn how to calm your own nervous system when you feel attacked. 2. Analyze which emotional wounds cause you to interpret her questions and emotional reactions as attacks, and learn how to process them in a healthy way.
Don’t confuse your intentions with the damage
You know your intentions. You know that you never meant to hurt her and that you feel awful when you see her in pain. But the fact is, you hurt her anyway. What matters to her right now is whether you’re becoming a safe husband who would never do anything like that again.
If you simply respond to her pain with “I didn’t mean to hurt you”, she may sense that you really mean it, but if you use intention to remove her pain, what she will hear is, “I don’t really want to face it, because it’s uncomfortable”.
Do: Be willing to face her pain
You never meant to hurt her, but you did. And if you are not willing to face her pain – really see it and feel it with her – she knows instinctively that you’ll have less problem doing it again. And she would probably be right.
If you learn to sit with her in her pain and be present without being defensive, you show her that you take her pain seriously and that you are capable of handling it even if it triggers your shame.
That, my friend, is one of the most effective trust-building skills you can ever have.
Don’t treat her questions or anger as attacks
It’s easy to feel attacked by repeated questions or outburst of anger. It’s even normal, because your brain instinctively interprets it as potential danger.
The problem is, if you do, you likely respond with irritability, defensiveness, or pressuring trust. That, friend, will make her feel even more unsafe with you. Because not only did you betray her trust, you are an unsafe person to be vulnerable with.
Do: Realize that any communication is a bid for connection
If she’s still in the relationship at all, you can bet your entire existence that even her outbursts of anger are bids for connection. If she didn’t want you or didn’t love you, she wouldn’t be there after the betrayal. Period.
That means, even her expressions of anger towards you are ways of trying to connect with you. The best thing you can do if you want to rebuild trust is to learn how to calm your own inner fire alarm, remind yourself that she isn’t attacking you, and learn to listen. Really listen.
Don’t try to “calm her down” when she’s upset
Sometimes, you may trick your brain into thinking that if your wife isn’t upset, your marriage is doing better. That’s your brain’s fire alarm reacting to a stressful situation. The result may be that you try to calm her down at the expense of actually helping her heal.
To her, that feels like you’re treating her pain with disdain, telling her that she’s overreacting. And if you treat her pain like an over-reaction, you are again indirectly saying “it wasn’t that bad”.
Do: Be curious about what she is feeling
Be aware that calm isn’t an indicator of your progress as a couple. Being upset is an important part of her healing process. She will need to process the injustice of the betrayal, the pain of the broken connection, and grieve the loss of the relationship she thought she had. If you try to simply “make her feel better” without allowing an actual healing process, you don’t help her heal. You prevent her healing.
If you want to rebuild your marriage, learn to be curious about what she is feeling. Encourage her expressions of emotions even if it feels scary. Encourage her to be emotionally open with you.
Don’t treat her boundaries as punishment
If you have kept your sexual behavior a secret from your wife, you have tried to control her. If you’re honest, you didn’t keep it a secret to protect her. You kept it a secret to protect yourself from her reactions if she found out. That means, you’ve tried to control her actions by controlling the stream of information going her way.
Now that everything is disclosed, while the power balance in your marriage is much more equal, you mainly feel that loss of control. That may mean that her boundaries make you feel like she is controlling you. The problem with that attitude is that you will likely pout about it, and your wife will know that you feel more sorry for yourself than you do about your betrayal and her pain.
Do: Learn to think of her boundaries as relational safety
Her boundaries are expressions of where she feels safe with you. They are not means of control. You aren’t less free because she now has better boundaries. You are just as free to violate her boundaries as you were to violate sexual exclusivity.
The main difference is that now she respects her own safety better, and she doesn’t necessarily believe you automatically know what creates relational safety.
That doesn’t make her too sensitive or controlling. That makes her wise.
Don’t pressure her to heal faster because you are tired of feeling like the bad guy.
It’s natural if you feel awful when you see your wife suffer. And I completely understand if you’re tired of the constant shame.
But it turns dangerous if you simply put band-aids on the wound, so you can stop feeling shameful about the damage you caused. There is a big difference between working to heal the relationship and wanting to stop the shame of feeling like the bad guy. If you simply work to stop feeling shameful, it will tell your wife that you are more concerned with your self-image than with her well-being.
Do: Understand that real healing takes deliberate work
Healing doesn’t simply take time. It takes learning how to create relational safety and emotional connection.
The best thing you can do in this case is learn how to process your own shame in a way that enables you to stay present with it without being overwhelmed by it.
Don’t try to get back to “normal”
It’s understandable that you want “normal” if your current state is living with constant shame. I get that a part of you may want to go back to the way it was before.
But don’t try to rebuild your marriage by getting back to what was “normal”. Your wife doesn’t want “normal”, because normal included betrayal and deception and the tendencies in you that made sexual addiction possible.
Do: Reframe your mindset to rebuild on vulnerability and strength
Be aware that the main reason you feel like getting back to normal is because you want to avoid being vulnerable. “Normal” felt safer, because you had more control, but that kind of control isn’t healthy. Not being in control requires a different level of relational vulnerability, and while that can feel scary, it’s healthy.
You don’t want normal. You want better and stronger. Work on becoming comfortable with being vulnerable.
Don’t shut down when she is sad
If you feel helpless when your wife is sad, and you have no idea what to do or what to say, I get it. Because, honestly, there isn’t much you can say that will take away her pain. There isn’t much you can do that will remove it.
The good news is, taking away her pain isn’t the goal. The goal is to help her heal by being present with her in her pain.
Do: Learn how to stay emotionally present
What she needs from you when she is sad, isn’t words or actions. She needs to know that you hear her, that you see her. That means you need to learn how to be emotionally present even when her pain triggers your shame.
Be willing to work on how you react when your shame is triggered. Be willing to learn emotional availability, vulnerability, and intimacy. Be intentional about learning empathy.
Emotional presence is the most important relational skill you can learn. With or without betrayal in the picture. But it’s crucial if you want to rebuild trust and connection after betrayal.
Don’t ask for trust
It’s understandable that you want to be trusted, because after betrayal, trust can feel like the maker-or-breaker of the relationship. But if you ask for trust, maybe even expect it, your wife can feel like she is being pressured. And pressure doesn’t build trust.
Do: Become trustworthy
Realize that trust isn’t necessarily a choice. Your wife didn’t choose to distrust you. In fact, if she distrusted you from the beginning, she probably wouldn’t have married you.
Betrayal taught her nervous system that you are capable of causing deep pain. That means, as long as you still feel relationally or sexually unsafe to her, her nervous system can’t calm down. That means, your job is to create enough safety over time to allow her nervous system to gradually settle.
And “over time” means practicing a lot of patience while continuously doing repair work. Consistency in repair work is the key to creating the safety your wife needs.
To making your marriage great!
Anita
Anita Kragelund Thimm
Founder of Standing Strong Project. Theologian, PSAP, PMAP, and BTRL.
Next Steps for Trust-Builders
FREE BEGINNER'S GUIDE
A free pdf-guide for Christian husbands who want to stop making things worse and start rebuilding trust.
ONGOING TEACHING
SSP’s membership for Christian husbands who desire to rebuild trust in their marriages on a stronger foundation of safety and connection.
